Disquiet in the Land

Today I have another guest blogger. Some of you are probably familiar with Monica the Mennobrarian, but if not, you'll want to visit her blog. If you've every tried any of her recipes, you know she has got to be a great cook. Her recipe for Bruschetta is phenomenal! Besides being a good cook and homemaker, Monica is also an awesome writer. I warn you that you may cry when you read this post… I did. The scene with her friend is what got me. That and what followed.
Here's Monica:
About three years ago, I was sitting in a conference session at the Elizabethtown College for Anabaptist Studies. The audience of this session was very diverse — academics, researchers, sociologists, Amish women, and at least one Old Order Bishop. A woman, well spoken and articulate, took the podium and recounted her personal story of living as part of a "black sheep" family in the Amish community in which she was raised, due largely to her father's mental illness. This woman told candidly of the isolation her family felt in their church community, how they were held up of the example of "how not to be" among her own people. And as she retold of her own personal struggles among a people who are often romanticized and held to a higher standard, every hair on my head stood up. Because if you had changed her story from an Amish setting to a Mennonite one, her story could have been mine.


That morning was my introduction to Saloma Furlong, though she was unaware of it. Imagine what it would be like to have an experience that you never speak of, something dark and shameful, and then someone gets up in front of a room full of people and tells of their own experience which matches your own in so many ways. That is what that moment was like for me. Although I had lingered after the session in hopes of speaking to her, Saloma was surrounded by people and I could not overcome my shyness to interrupt and introduce myself. But I didn't forget her, and her story stayed with me. It was my story too.

The fact is, no matter what your church or belief system, having a mentally ill parent will affect you in ways that you aren't even aware of until moments happen in your adult years that bring it to light. For me, an inability to know what a "normal" family looked like was a heavy price to pay and took much work to overcome. As a child, we walked on eggshells constantly because there was no way to know when my father's next mood swing or violent outburst could occur, and we feared doing something innocent that would trigger an episode. Knocking over a glass of orange juice could cause an eruption that would end in smashed household objects or walls. Equally unsettling was his random propensity to fly high as a kite, in near manic moods of euphoria. You would smile along and agree readily with everything he said, in hopes that this mood would not pass and there would be no more dark days. Episodes triggered by his illness often led to physically and verbally abusive behavior. Where there is mental illness, there is always some for of abuse or neglect taking place. Dealing with such behavior in your own family is hard enough, but having to cope with it as part of a church community brings a new set of challenges. Families, churches, and communities all have limited power in these situations. No one can demand that a mentally ill person get treatment or seek help. And yet the power they do have can be easily misdirected to penalize the very people they want to help. I'm not blaming any one person or church, people do the best that they can with what they know. But the feelings Saloma described of being part of and yet separate, completely alone, from those around her were feelings that I could identify with in the deepest way.

Once, I can remember as a little girl sitting on the front steps of my friend's house, crying after one of my father's episodes. The confusion I felt as to why he acted that way, and my mother's inability to articulate the cause of it weighed heavily on my young mind. My childhood friend found the compassion and maturity to wrap her arms around me and comfort me in whatever small way another little girl could. Soon, her mother opened the door to see what was going on, and as I tried to explain my anguish and the happenings in our home, she coldly declared that she did not want to hear about this and closed the door. And that was symbolic of how many people chose to "help" us. By saying they did not want to know about it and closing the door. Because if you bury your head in the sand, it will all go away. I got the message loud and clear. If you didn't talk about things, then they didn't exist. That notion still appalls me to the bone. When dealing with abusive situations where families are in jeopardy, silence is the enemy. Always.

But people do the best they can with what they know, and that was the best that we knew. I loved the best of what my upbringing had to offer, but it took many years to find comfort in those things and incorporate them into my life after years of healing. That I can find many things to love in my family, church, and growing up years, is a true mark of my recovery from the unstable and chaotic environment that family life often was. That I could find joy in Jesus after years of a deafening silence, can only be attributed to God's work in my life, and I can take little credit for the positive changes that have happened since.

I have been blessed to see some positive changes in our churches, including a greater awareness of mental health issues and treatment options. There is still much work to be done. It will always be my passion to break the silence about these issues, as hard as it is for me to talk about it, being a somewhat naturally reserved and private person. How we respond to the "black sheep" among us not only affects our relationship with God, but can either encourage or obliterate the spiritual state of someone else. God does not have black sheep in his family, though there are some of us who seem to be set apart, separated for some unknown purpose. Having been raised in an environment that values uniformity, that is a hard thing to acknowledge even today. The painfulness of having a mentally ill family member is eclipsed only by the pain of feeling like an outsider. It serves well to remind us that Jesus was considered an outsider too. Lets reach out and help one another and be an encouragement, not in silence, but with a joyful noise. 

Sharing is caring

7 thoughts on “Disquiet in the Land”

  1. What a great post, Monica. I know that had to be difficult but also cathartic in a way. We find strength in those who understand and can empower us to deal and heal and know what we’re going through. It sounds like you found that in Saloma. You’ve come a long way, baby! So many people continue to live as “victims” and you’ve chosen not to, but rather acknowledge what happened and still open your heart to accept the good in life and the blessings that have come your way, which I know you’d agree are many. Prayers for continued healing and I’m so glad you shared that. ♥

  2. Much I could identify with in this paragraph. . . And that was symbolic of how many people chose to “help” us. By saying they did not want to know about it and closing the door. Because if you bury your head in the sand, it will all go away. I got the message loud and clear. If you didn’t talk about things, then they didn’t exist. That notion still appalls me to the bone. When dealing with abusive situations where families are in jeopardy, silence is the enemy. Always.
    Thank you for sharing, Monica. I hope as more and more of us speak up and out against abuse in any form, that the tide will slowly turn in our churches and homes.

  3. What a wonderful post. Both my husband and I grew up in similar circumstances and yes people either don’t want to hear about it or in our cases are taught that it is wrong and we are to try harder, that it is either our own fault, or that we are to not listen to Satan. Though definitely Satan can and does use mental illness in his schemes, the Lord always has other plans and though we may not totally not ever know what all those plans entail, one thing that can be certain is that for those of us who have been in this situation, we can draw strength from God and learn to be there for others and be part of the healing rather than ignoring it. I love your writing, thank you for all the times you have taught me something. God bless you and your family.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top