Amish Humor

Lindsae wrote: My questions is about humor in Amish culture. Do Amish people appreciate things like satire, sarcasm, etc.? Do children and families tell jokes, sing funny songs, and pull harmless pranks on one another? Do they use humor as a way to diffuse tension, deal with grief, or make people feel better?

Lindsae, the Amish have a very earthy brand of humor. They can be very funny as a group. Very often their humor centers around the human condition. Occasionally, it is at the expense of someone less fortunate, which isn’t funny in my opinion. In this post, I am focusing on what I do find funny — what David has dubbed “Amish humor.”

My maternal grandfather was a prankster. There is a family story about his first date with my grandmother that demonstrates the rascal in him. The story goes that my grandmother was staying at her aunt’s house in Geauga County, Ohio. (She was from Mercer County, Pennsylvania). She was in her late teens at the time. A young man in the community asked my grandfather, Joe, if he knows where she is staying. Joe directed his friend out to the Troy area, into the farthest reaches of the community. While his friend was on his wild goose chase, Joe went down the road and asked my grandmother, Saloma, for a date. The rest is history.

Another “prank” that backfired happened when a cousin went out one night to “surprise” her husband, who was working outside in the dark. She was planning to sneak up on him and startle him. She startled him, all right. She fell down a cellar hole and broke her foot. This doesn’t sound funny , but after the foot is healed, it is funny… in a twist of fate kind of way.

I remember in Amish school, when one of the older boys had a birthday, he had to watch his back. Inevitably, a group of the boys would sneak up behind him and “hoist” him above their heads as a birthday prank.

The day after my father’s funeral, my mother was still laughing at something my uncle had said to her when people were outside visiting after the funeral. Mem was going to sit down in one of those white plastic lawn chairs, but Uncle Gid said, “Here, let’s move it onto the sidewalk since the ground is so soft. I don’t need to see moonshine in the daytime.” When Mem laughed, she didn’t make a sound. Her face would get very red and her considerable bosom would bounce and then occasionally she would have to catch another breath and that was all you could hear of her laughter. That’s what it was like when she told us that story.

I know a young woman who just left the Amish and she has a wonderful sense of humor. She and I have had fun joking in the Amish language. I told her the story of two older women in my home community. One of them had dementia and could no longer walk and when she saw another woman walk by with a cane, she said, “Dat gehts sie mit mia schtock! Flutsch!” That means, there she goes with my cane!” “Flutsch” is a slightly derogatory name for a woman in the Amish language. I don’t know if anyone knows the exact meaning of the word. 

One morning, this young woman was at my house, and she saw an older woman walking by, carrying a cane. She said, “Dat gehts sie mit mia schtock und sie iss net even am’s yousa. Flutsch!” (There she goes with my cane, and she’s not even using it!”) She is an older woman who has been walking by our house ever since we moved here. She moves very quickly for someone her age. Now I’ll always smile when she walks by… I’ll never see her the same way again. To make this even funnier, I just looked out my window and the same woman was walking by, carrying her cane, but not using it. 

I cannot think of too many examples of satire or sarcasm in Amish humor. I would have to answer “no” to the question of whether they appreciate it, at least in general.

I cannot think of too many examples of the Amish using humor to deal with grief or diffuse tension. There are situations that they take very seriously, such as when someone is dying, wakes, funerals, and communion services (especially if a minister is being ordained). They would consider it inappropriate for people to joke in such situations.

It was in such a context that my mother did surprise me once. It was a week before she died, and we all knew she was dying. There were a whole group of people sitting around her, visiting in the living room, mostly my siblings and my brother Joe’s family. Mem said in a very serious tone of voice, “I would like to ask a favor.” I was thinking, “Oh boy, here it comes — she’s going to ask all of us who left to come back and join the Amish or she’s going to beg me not to ever get my life story published.” I knew if I denied her anything on her deathbed, I’d feel guilty for the rest of my life. So imagine my surprise when she said, “I’d like Saloma to do her chicken act… one more time.” I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry — especially when she said those last three words. Now I was supposed to perform in the midst of all this tension? I was honestly so relieved to not have to deny her a dying wish, that I managed to get up and perform my chicken and rooster act for her. I developed this some years ago, where I demonstrate what a chicken does before it lays its egg and then the cackle after it lays its egg. Then I imitate what a young rooster sounds like when he first begins to crow and how the granddaddy rooster shows him how it’s really done. In the moment I got up to “perform” Mem seemed to want us to laugh instead of cry, so I had to think of myself as a chicken.

So, yes, the Amish have a wonderful sense of humor. It took some adjusting to get used to the humor in mainstream culture, which tends not to poke fun at the self or one another as much as the Amish brand does.

Thanks, Lindsae, for this great question.  
Sharing is caring

7 thoughts on “Amish Humor”

  1. Oh, I enjoyed hearing your stories. Wunderbar (did I spell that correctly?). When my beloved uncle died (only son of my grandparents and beloved brother to my Mom and Aunt), it was particularly solemn because he was only 43. I was a teenager and people were so sad you could worry that they would break. Well, my poor grandmother went and put her arms around him and listed his upper body out of the casket. When she did that, she dislodged his toupee which was on with some sort of less-than permanent glue. The higher she lifted, the farther the toupee slid back his head – until the undertaker came and took him from her to place him back in the casket, rearranging his hair as he did so. A gentle word to my grandmother reminded her that the hair was only lightly applied. I think that bit of humor saved the emotions of my Mom and Aunt that tragic day.

  2. You really nailed the sense of humor on this one. It is definitely different than mainstream humor, and I think the emphasis on pranks makes for a lot of funny family stories over the years. I could tell you of a prank years ago when a bride and groom found their bedroom furniture relocated to the middle of a field. But I won’t tell you about it because it could implicate the person telling you. ;)

  3. Hello there! This article couldn’t be written much better! Looking through this article reminds me of my previous roommate! He always kept talking about this. I will send this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a very good read. Thanks for sharing!
    Also visit my web blog : click here

  4. When my mother was on her deathbed, and lingering, seemingly unable to die, we would go say a few words to her every so often, I guess to let her know we were there with her. On one of those times when I’d gone to her side, she opened her eyes and said “gell, so un ongeshick!” Still cracks me up! :)

  5. I agree that the Amish love to laugh and that a lot of their humor is in telling stories on themselves. Does anyone else remember those stories of the woman on the train who wanted a ‘kissee’ (a pillow)? The conductor joshes back, asking if she wants it on her check and she says, ‘No. I want it right here.’ and pats her backside?

    Or the story about the man who comes to the farm looking for her husband and the wife says, ‘He’s out back of the barn milking the calves’? Gets worse as it goes on. ha

    On the other hand, I also know of the ‘de-pantsing’ that older boys often sprang on younger self-important boys.

  6. Hey, I think your blog might be having browser
    compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Ie,
    it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer,
    it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!

    Other then that, fantastic blog!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top