The Amish “Phenomenon” and Women’s Standing in the Community

Karen wrote: When you were in the Amish, were you aware of the fascination the English had with the Amish? When you were around the English in a public setting, did you ever feel like you were a bit of a living museum (for lack of a better description)?

It seems as though amish women, although given few real choices throughout their lives and subject to an extremely male-dominant society, are very highly regarded within the Amish culture. Is that true? I know your family had other issues but I’m speaking of the Amish culture in general.

Karen, good questions. Yes, I was always aware of the fascination for the Amish, even while I was living in the community. And it did feel like we were a phenomenon, in many ways. But the funny thing is, I enjoyed the attention from the “English” because at least I felt unique in that. It is not really okay to feel unique or different within the community. I was so starved for being seen as “someone” that even this was good enough for me. I am embarrassed to say this now, but it was true then.

Your second question is a bit harder for me to answer — first of all, it is impossible to answer almost any question about the Amish in general, for each community is different in so many ways. And even within each community there can be differences from one church district to another. And then there are the individuals in each family, and how they regard one another. So this question is as hard to answer as trying to describe how women in the mainstream society are regarded in our culture.

What I can tell you is that I noticed my mother was very highly regarded by the people in the community in her later years, especially the last year of her life, after my father died. Many of her nieces would state emphatically that Katie was their favorite aunt. She used to get visitors who liked to come and spend the day with her, or an out-of-town niece who liked to stay with her overnight. I don’t really have a sense of her relationship with the men in the community, especially the elders of the church.

It took my mother that many years to come into this “reputation.” Before that she was often criticized for not being a more submissive wife, and for not quelling the rebellion in her daughters (as if she could have). She was such a capable and intelligent person and many people were envious of that, so they tended to cut her down, which they thought boosted their standing. This kind of “bringing someone down a notch” was one of the most punitive aspects of living in my original community and it is one of the things that drove me out — not once but twice.

Sorry I cannot answer your last question more definitively, Karen. Often I have to bring such questions back to my own experience because I cannot speak for the Amish in general.
Sharing is caring

5 thoughts on “The Amish “Phenomenon” and Women’s Standing in the Community”

  1. This is interesting, Saloma. I often wondered how the Amish community felt about the gawking tourists. I assumed that they didn’t mind earning income from selling their wares to the “outsiders”.

    Thanks for sharing!

  2. Saloma,
    Oh, such interesting information! I am so happy inside about your Mother being recognized as she was in the latter years of her life. Maternal genetics must have been passed on! You have accomplised so much, I think you knew all along that life would be different if you could only be your own guide!

    Debbie S.

  3. Thanks so much for answering my questions! This is so interesting.

    Just one follow-up question….are the English as much a curiosity to the Amish as the Amish are to us?

  4. Karen, some of the Amish tend to turn the intrigue about their culture into money… Lancaster County is much more so than my home community, for instance.

    Debbie, thank you very much for your compliments. It is nice to be understood… you are absolutely right, I really did have a sense that my life would be different if I could be my own guide… that is actually a nice way to put it.

    Karen, I would say no to your question… partly because the mainstream culture is an open book, while the Amish are not. And the Amish do have quite a bit of interaction with the outside world, so it is no mystery for them, really. I think some of the intrigue about the Amish is because their culture is so mysterious to most people.

    Thanks, all for your questions.


  5. The amish are truly a unique people. Their way of life is not really so bad in many ways I envy their closeness,and slower pace. I find much about their way that is very peaceful and family oriented,thats a good thing. Blessings jane

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top